AppleTV is just what I said it was when it was announced, and people started going on about being a 'TiVo killer'. It is an Apple Media Center Extender, plain and simple. That doesn't mean it isn't good for what it is, but it is not a DVR, or anything like it. I don't see getting one. TiVo will have more broadband content offerings this year, and I already have those. And I'll probably be getting a SlingCatcher, which will also have options for broadband content - no PC/Mac needed.
I was hoping for a real widescreen iPod. Guess I'll keep waiting.